Renting vs. Owning a Home: Beyond the Mainstream Fairy Tales

Sem título1

Whether to rent or to buy the place in which you live is a major decision. It doesn’t just affect how much money you have left at the end of the month, it also affects your lifestyle and the size of the savings you accumulate over the years.

Of the two options, the bias often veers towards ownership: It’s a big business for everyone from mortgage lenders to real estate agents to home improvement stores, so we are bombarded with the message that home ownership is the key to happiness.

But owning isn’t universally better than renting, nor is renting always simpler than owning. Consider the pros and cons of each to figure out whether renting or owning is best for you. Let’s start with useful considerations .

1. ILLIQUID ASSET

Sem título3

Real estate is the original illiquid asset. You might not be able to sell when you want if the housing market is down, and even if it’s up, there are significant transaction costs when you sell. The seller’s agent usually charges 5% to 6% of the home purchase price when the deal closes. If you live in a democratic western country, you may also face capital gains taxes in the profit from selling your home.

2. RENTING IS THROW AWAY MONEY?

First of all, you need a place to live, and that always costs money. Second, while it’s true that you aren’t building equity with monthly rent payments, you also aren’t building equity with much of the money you’ll put into owning a house.

Perhaps the biggest throw-away expense is mortgage interest, which can make up nearly all of your monthly payment in the early years of a long-term mortgage.

The overall cost of home ownership tends to be higher than the overall cost of renting, even if the monthly mortgage payment is similar to (or lower than) the monthly cost to rent.

Take this example: You borrow $100,000 at 4% for 30 years. Your first monthly payment will be $477.42, of which $333.33 is interest and $144.08 is principal. It will be about 13 years before more of your monthly payment goes toward principal than toward interest, and in total, you’ll lose $71,869.51 in interest.  Despite the low value ($100,000), a real scenario will be explained below.

3. EXPENSES

Let’s look at the numbers to buy a home valued at $1.4 million in US.

Sem título

Mortgage – You would have to put down a minimum of 20%, which is $280,000. This would give you a mortgage of $1,120,000 at a 4% interest rate over 30 years. The payments for this mortgage (30-year fixed) would add up to about $64,160 per year.

Property Taxes – Tax rates vary widely among jurisdictions. In some jurisdictions, property is taxed based on its classification based on similar use: residential, commercial, industrial, vacant, and blighted real property. In Washington D.C. for instance property occupancy is incentivized by taxing residential property at 0.85 percent of assessed value but vacant residential property at 5 percent of assessed value. Taxes on my property example were $25,000. I assumed a 1.5% property tax rate.

Sem título4

Real Estate Transfer Tax – Is a tax that may be imposed by states, counties, or municipalities on the privilege of transferring real property within the jurisdiction. In Europe, rates between 2% and 4% are a general rate. In the USA, total transfer taxes can range between very small (0.01% in Colorado) to relatively large (4% in the city of Pittsburgh). Taxes on my property example were $28,000. I assumed a 2% real estate transfer tax.

Property Insurance – This was estimated at about $3,600 a year.

Heat – The estimate on heat was about $7,500 per year.

Water and Sewer – Average annual cost of maintenance and a new system was about $1,000 a year.

Electricity – This bill was about $4,600 a year.

Appliances – This was estimated at about $1,000 a year.

Home Repairs – I estimated it at about 1%, or $14,000 a year.

Lawn Care and Snow Removal – This can vary on the size of the property and the location, but I estimated it at about $4,500 a year.

By my accounts … wow, you’re screwed up buddy: $153,360 a year.

 

4. REAL ESTATE BUILD WEALTH

While home ownership is often touted as a way to build wealth, your home can lose value. Lots of value. The acceptable neighborhood you moved in could decline. A major employer can leave the area, causing a significant population decline and a surplus of housing, or there could be a residential construction boom – either of which keep prices down. You might buy a house for $200,000 tomorrow and in 30 years find that it’s still worth $200,000, meaning you’ve lost money after inflation. It is an improbable scenario, but it is possible. Do you know Detroit?

Even renovation projects don’t often increase the value of your home by more than what you spend on them. On average, you’ll get back 62 cents for every dollar you spend on a home improvement project, according to “Remodeling” magazine’s 2015 Cost vs. Value Report.

Sem título

5. TAX DEDUCTION

Another bit of misleading conventional wisdom: Get a mortgage to get the tax deduction. True, the home mortgage interest deduction reduces your out-of-pocket expenses for mortgage interest early in your loan term (and the property tax deduction reduces property taxes), as long as you’re itemizing. But tax deductions are not a reason to buy a house. Here’s why: For every $1 you spend in interest, you might save 25¢ on your tax bill. You’re not coming out ahead. What’s more, as you pay down your mortgage and the proportion of your payment that covers interest decreases, so will the tax break.

5. NUMBERS DON’T LIE

A) The average American moves 11 times in their lives. Five of those moves occur between the ages of 20 and 40 and two of the moves occur between 40 and 60. In short, most home buyers won’t be able to reach the break-even point on home ownership.

B) Home ownership is also less cost-effective in the long term. Going back to the late 1800’s the inflation-adjusted return for the stock market is 2.03% per year, whereas home ownership is 0.33%. Both beat inflation, but over 125 years the growth of stocks was 12x whereas homes were only 1.5x.

Sem título2

C) Moving is expensive. A renter might pay $1000 for moving services, whereas the home owner has to pay $1000 plus ~6% commission on the sale, inspection costs, legal fees, etc. On a $1,4 M property just the commission would be $84,000.

D) Moving isn’t always predictable. People have more kids. People get divorced. People lose their jobs or better job opportunities might open up elsewhere.

E) A mortgage payment might be comparable to monthly rent. However the extra expenses like fees, taxes, insurance, property taxes and maintenance can contribute significantly to the monthly cost.

 

6. THE BOTTOM LINE

The biggest advantage of renting is the flexibility to relocate relatively easily. The situation in which you bought your home can change. Renting can offer a substantially greater number and variety of amenities than buying. For example, upscale apartment buildings can offer a swimming pool, tennis court, and on-site gym. The monthly rent is comparatively lower than a mortgage for a property with the same attributes.

Buying a house gives you the opportunity to choose a unique and distinct architectural style and to personalize it. An owner obviously has far more flexibility to make improvements to a home than a renter. But this freedom comes with the responsibility of keeping up with maintenance and repairs.

Rationally speaking, renting is the best option. But we’re talking about humans, damn it. Other considerations such as emotional, environmental, and flexibility can sometimes outweigh decisions that may not be financially justified.

Well… Now you have the data,  information and opinion. Make the choices according to your goals. Make the odds in your favor.

 

This article is owned by the Termos Reais and does not constitute investment advice. Termos Reais is not responsible for any decisions, damages or other losses resulting from or related to the use of information, data, analyzes or opinions and their respective use. Although the data in this article is collected from trusted sources, accuracy and completeness can not be guaranteed. Termos Reais does not give investment advice or act as an investment advisor. All data, information and opinions are subject to change without notice.

© 2017 Termos Reais. All rights reserved. Reproduction by any means is prohibited.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Renting vs. Owning a Home: Beyond the Mainstream Fairy Tales

  1. It’s a good topic.

    A mortgage can kill your financial independence. The “American Dream”, go to a college, work in a good company, get a wife, get a mortgage, stay stuck in the same place for more over than 25 years, send your son to a college… all this is pretty much 80’s for me.

    I think renting a house fits for the majority of people. Why? People change jobs, marriages, cities, a lot of time. Even their marriages have more than 50% to a divorce, so someone has to pay the mortgage that remains in the background.

    Like

  2. TR,

    Este é um belo post mas tenho que alertar apenas para a o tipo de compra que se pretende fazer. Se for o sonho de ter uma bela casa para criar filhos, galinha, horta, cuidar da piscina e viver o resto da vida então digamos que não tem preço pois neste caso o que se procura é o bem estar e a realização de um sonho, neste caso a pessoa compra o sonho e o conforto e o investimento não é financeiro e sim emocional e satisfatório.

    Já se for pensar pelo lado mais reacional, que na minha opinião é o que acontece hoje com os jovens, nunca ninguém compara uma casa ou um apartamento. Eu mesmo gosto de viajar e conhecer lugares e já morei em vários lugares do Brasil e até no exterior um pouquinho então porque me prenderia, ou melhor, prenderia todo meu patrimônio a um só lugar?

    Sem contar que realmente o custo é muito maior que alugar. Com o mesmo valor da casa aplicado você mora melhor do que se comprasse a mesma casa. Outro dia fui fazer uma pesquisa de casa em Búzios para alugar e ví uma casa próximo a praia de João Fernandes que é bem localizada, com piscina e 4 quartos por 3500 ao mês. Se você tem um apartamento que custe 450 mil já tem este valor com facilidade agora imagine se esta casa custa 450 mil? Claro que não, deve passar de um milhão fácil.

    Pra finalizar tenho um amigo que achou que ia ficar rico comprando imóveis em 2013. Comprou 2 apartamentos e uma loja comercial. Está passando dificuldades pra manter tudo gastando todo o salário e ainda tendo que entrar no cheque especial adstringências vezes. Não vende pelo preço que acha justo e fica esperando o milagre de subir novamente de valor. Já falei pra ele vender no preço que der e aplicar isso em outra cosia ao menos um apartamento pra se livrar de outras dividas.

    Enfim, dá pra escrever muitas ideias sobre isso e teria que ter um post específico para colocar algumas ideias e soluções para algumas pessoas que não sabem o que fazer neste momento frio do mercado imobiliário.

    Abraço!

    Like

    • BPM, excelentes colocações!

      O objetivo do post é passar um cenário realista em questões de gastos, custo oportunidade e afins.

      A questão subjetiva é inerente a cada um de nós. Afinal somos humanos. Então isso varia de pessoa para pessoa, no tocante a afinidades, necessidades, interesses, etc.

      E, por favor, escreva sim seu artigo sobre esta questão dos imóveis. Seus posts são muito bons!

      Serei o primeiro a comentar!

      Abs amigo

      Like

  3. Esqueci de mencionar que em 2014 escrevi sobre comprar ou alugar mas por motivos operacionais retirei o post do ar. Como o post tá lá como rascunho, em breve republico ele.

    Abraço!

    Like

  4. Pingback: Termos Reais na Estrada: O Toque de Midas da $oja | Termos Reais

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s